Thursday, January 15, 2009

[barefoot doctors] primary health care


This was more than a little interesting about the state of medicine in China when the communists came to power on the backs of the peasantry:

With trained doctors in short supply, the central government in 1951 decided that basic healthcare in the countryside should be provided by health workers rather than by fully trained physicians. In 1957, there were more than 200,000 such "village doctors" whose administration was under the responsibility of the local authorities.

While these village doctors had received only basic training and could not treat complicated cases, their impact was considerable and especially so in preventing minor ills or wounds from developing into complex medical problems and in implementing nation-wide vaccination campaigns.

After the cultural revolution, they were allowed to upgrade to be local village doctors but then:

The rural health system started to collapse in the late 1970s and early 1980s as a result of China's economic liberalization and the privatization of agriculture ... many diseases that had been eradicated re-emerged in the countryside.

Primary care, even in the cities, is almost non-existent and with no independent doctors or neighborhood clinics, people have to go to hospitals even for simple healthcare needs.

With hospitals told to finance their own costs and 79% of the population having no health insurance, the burden on the average Chinese is considerable, with the result that many simply cannot afford any healthcare at all.

Primary care in the UK is eerily reminiscent of the Chinese situation:

The NHS inherited a maldistribution of resources, especially in London. where the main hospitals were concentrated in the centre of the city. London's lack of adequate primary care coverage and over-reliance on hospitals for treatment have created recurring problems.

The Labour government in the 1970s attempted to redress the balance by transferring resources from hospital care to primary care, limiting the growth of better served regions, and favouring the development of some underfunded specialties, like medicine for the elderly. This led to hospital closures. The policy was continued by the Conservatives in the 1980s.

As a person who doesn't use the health services [touch wood], I can't comment on how bad it is in the UK but it doesn't seem to be running much better than in China.

3 comments:

  1. I can say that the treatment I receive for my skin and eye problems are very good. My surgery, the Western Road Medical centre in Romford, is excellent

    ReplyDelete
  2. The problem with the NHS at the moment is that the government have set targets that have to be met. They have provided posts for too many administrators to monitor and provide statistics etc. The administrators get paid higher wages than the health care workers and sap up the cash that should be used in more productive areas. Removing the administrative layer will free up the cash to be used more productively.

    It will lead to better care and reduced waiting times etc. At the moment the focus is on producing targets, which is not what health care is supposed to be about!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I found that the one time I was at the doctors, to register, it was bureaucratic but also friendly.

    ReplyDelete

Comments need a moniker of your choosing before or after ... no moniker, not posted, sorry.